GE CAPITAL
OVERVIEW OF HEDGING
Management of Market-Related Risks
Interest rate movements |
Swaps |
Cash flow hedge accounting is used to hedge variability
in cash flows associated with: Recognized assets and liabilities with variable terms; or Forecasted transactions |
Fair value hedge accounting is used to hedge an entity's
exposure to changes in fair value, attributable to a particular risk,
relating to: Recognized assets or liabilities with fixed terms; or Unrecognized firm commitments |
Hedging of a net investment in a foreign operation continues to be allowed |
Formal documentation of the hedging relationship, its objectives and strategy, and its effectiveness |
The hedging relationship must be expected to be highly effective at inception and on an ongoing basis |
There are special rules for using written options and basis swaps as hedging instruments |
At inception, must document: Hedging relationship Risk management objective and strategy Identification of instrument and hedged item Nature of risk Method of assessing effectiveness |
Additional documentation required for: 1. Firm commitment: reasonable method of recognizing adjustments in earnings 2. Forecasted transaction: transaction specifics (timing, nature, amount, price) evidence supporting management's assertion that the transaction is probable |
FAS 133 does not allow hedge accounting for the following
items: Net income hedging Items that are marked-to-market through income (except foreign currency denominated transactions) Equity method investments Equity in a consolidated subsidiary Business combinations Non-financial assets/liabilities - the designated risk being hedged must be the risk of changes in the FV of the entire asset/liability |
In order to maintain hedge accounting, the hedged item and hedging instrument must be highly effective |
However, any ineffectiveness must be taken to earnings (with one exception - discussed later) |
Process for measuring effectiveness is not set by the standard |
Ongoing: Evaluate at least quarterly Cumulative versus period methodologies Statistical techniques may be appropriate/used |
If an improved measurement method is identified then: Must terminate and re-designate hedge relationships Apply prospectively |
If high effectiveness ceases: May re-designate new hedging relationship prospectively; or Hedge accounting discontinued prospectively |
Derivative | ![]() ![]() |
Hedged Item |
Derivative | ![]() ![]() |
Hedged Item |
Derivative | ![]() ![]() |
Hedged Item |
Derivative | ![]() ![]() repricing dates |
Hedged Item |
Derivative | ![]() ![]() |
Hedged Item |
Derivative | ![]() ![]() (e.g., LIBOR versus Prime) |
Hedged Item |
Utilization of an IRS to synthetically alter fixed rate debt to a floating rate obligation |
Utilization of FX forwards/swaps on foreign currency
denominated transactions (e.g., foreign denominated debt) |
Available when key terms of an interest rate swap and hedged items meet certain conditions |
Accounting model: Assume perfectly effective No requirement to reassess effectiveness |
Short-cut method may not be used for hedges of risks other than interest rate risk (e.g. foreign currency risk) |
All:
Notional amount matches principal |
Cash Flow Hedges
All cash flows are designated as hedged |
Fair Value Hedges
Expiration dates match |
Forward contract Spot price Interest (time value) Carrying costs |
Option Intrinsic value Time value Interest Volatility value |
Market arbitrage effects |
Only specified components may be excluded: For option contracts Intrinsic value: Time value can be excluded Minimum value (intrinsic + discounting): Volatility value can be excluded For a Forward or Futures Contract Spot prices: Difference between spot and forward/futures price can be excluded |
Excluded Portion is Included in Earnings Based on Its Changes in Fair Value |
Equity securities hedging - options Typically use only intrinsic value to assess effectiveness; therefore, time value will be recognized in income each period |
Foreign currency denominated variable rate debt hedged
using short-term forwards Management may decide not to apply hedge accounting for these instruments given their short tenor |
FX hedging - swap/forward Management must determine whether to assess effectiveness based on spot or forward rate |
FX hedging - option DIG currently reviewing this issue; tentative indications appear to require the use of spot FX rate in determining the intrinsic value of an option |
Pools of items Loans with similar interest and maturities FX exposures |
Multiple hedging instruments (combination of options and swaps) |
Dynamic hedging Mortgage servicing rights Interest only strips and other prepayable financial instruments |
A hedge must be highly effective at inception and on an ongoing basis |
Effectiveness will be measured at the end of each quarter |
Evaluation of effectiveness must be consistent with the entity's risk management strategy |
Even though a hedge may be highly effective, the income statement may still contain hedge ineffectiveness |
Currently, there is no definitive method of evaluating hedge effectiveness |
Prospectively, mark-to-market derivative through earnings |
For cash flow accounting, amount in OCI is evaluated for removal based on the forecasted transaction (or future cash settlement) (i.e., if the forecasted transaction remains probable, the amount will remain in OCI until the transaction occurs) |
For fair value accounting, previous basis adjustments are accounted for based on the underlying item (i.e., if the hedged item was a loan, the adjusted basis (discount/premium) would be amortized to earnings consistent with current accounting for discounts/premiums on loans) |
INTRODUCTION AND OVERVIEW
FAS 133 SEMINAR
June 19-21, 2000
Schedule |
Breaks |
Lunch |
Other administrative matters |
Why FASB changed the rules |
New definition of derivatives |
New criteria to qualify for hedge accounting |
How does it affect me? |
What should I be concerned about? |
What should I do next? |
Existing Model was: |
Derivatives Are Assets or Liabilities |
The Only Relevant Measure for Derivatives is Fair Value |
Only Assets and Liabilities Should be Recorded As Such |
Special Hedge Accounting for Qualified Transactions |
Fair Value Fixed Rate Assets/Liabilities Firm Commitments |
Cash Flow Variable Rate Assets/Liabilities Forecasted Transactions |
Foreign Currency Firm Commitments Forecasted Transactions Net Investments |
Significant Paradigm Shift from Old Accounting |
Fair Value Hedge Provides Protection Against Changes in Value Caused by Fixed Rates or Prices | ||
Accounting Model | Measurement of Derivative Change in Fair Value ![]() |
Earnings |
Accounting Model | Measurement of Hedged Item Offsetting Gain or Loss Attributable to Risk Being Hedged ![]() |
Earnings |
Cash Flow Hedge Provides Protection Against Changes in Cash Flows Caused by Variable Rates or Prices | |||
Accounting Model | Measurement of Derivative Change in Fair Value |
![]() Effective |
OCI (Equity) (1) ![]() |
Accounting Model | (1) Based on Timing of Earnings Impact of Hedged Item (interest, cost of sales, depreciation) |
![]() Ineffective |
Earnings |
Foreign Currency |
FAS 52 Still Largely Applicable |
Hedge Accounting Was Limited to: Fair Value Hedge of Unrecognized Firm Commitments Cash Flow Hedge of Forecasted Transactions Net Investment in Foreign Operations |
Amendment Expanded Range of F/X Hedges |
Financial Statements Earnings Volatility Volatility in Recorded Assets and Liabilities |
Implementation Issues |
Uses Derivatives To Convert Interest Rate And/or FX Risk to Counterparty Credit Risk |
Reduce Funding Costs By About $70 Million (Pre-Tax) Per Year |
Board Policy Treasury Executes All Derivatives in GECC AAA Counterparty Rating for 5 Years+ AA Rating For < 5 Years Downgrade Language Below A- |
Derivatives Provide Flexibility and Lower Cost Of Funding |
Current Strategy |
FASB 133 Strategy |
Principal Amount 12/31/98($MM) |
Incremental Cost Per Annum Basis Points/$MM |
Impact of Funding Strategy | |
US Funding | |||||
Issue US Commercial Paper & Swap to Fixed USD Fixed Foreign Currency Debt Swapped to Fixed USD Floating Foreign Currency Debt Swapped to Fixed USD |
Issue Fixed USD Debt Issue Fixed USD Debt Issue Fixed USD Debt |
$11,884 |
10 bp/$17 |
USID Fixed Rate Notes Multiple Currencies Floating Rate Notes Multiple Currencies |
Fixed Rate Notes - USD Fixed Rate Notes -USD Fixed Rate Notes - USD |
Foreign Currency Funding | |||||
Synthetic Floating Foreign Debt Swapped to Fixed Foreign Currency Fixed Foreign Currency 1 Debt Swapped to Floating Foreign Currency |
Issued Fixed Foreign Debt Issue Floating Foreign 2 Debt |
$18,678 |
10 bp/$19 |
Fixed/Floating Notes Multiple Currencies Fixed Rate Notes Multiple Currencies |
Fixed Rate Notes-Single Currency Floating Rate Notes-Single Currency |
SFAS 133 Reduces Funding Alternatives And Flexibility |
Reduction of Funding Costs Matched Funding Swaps |
Exposure Management Mortgage
Services
$21.4 |
Derivatives Are Used For Exposure Management, As Well As Reducing Funding Costs |
OTC Shares Ownership |
|||
OTC Business Business Business OTC | |||
Define Measure Analyze Design Verify | |||
Project Objectives------> | Project Planning/ Management |
Process Implementation ------> |
Transition to Process Owners |
Dedicated Team Focused on Specific DMADV Goals Technical Interpretation with FASB & GE Create Center of Excellence at Corp. Treasury |
Complete GECS Project Implementation Plan/Timeline Inform Businesses; Create Awareness of Paradigm Shift in Accounting, Systems and Hedging Strategies |
Monitor Earnings Volatility, Rate Shock, Accuracy & Cycle Time CTQs Measure Defects (e.g., Derivatives Treated Improperly On New Systems, Unidentified Embedded Derivatives) |
Ensure Business Process Management Activities Are In Place Institutionalize Policies & Procedures Used for Hedging Activities and to Identify/ Account for New Derivatives |
Project Evolving Real Time...Success Is Critical |
|
|
DIG Issues/Amendments
SFAS 133
An Overview of the Amendment of
SFAS 133 (SFAS 138)
No conflict with or modifications to the basic model of SFAS 133 |
No delay in the effective date of the standard |
Implementation efforts would be eased for a large number of constituents |
Hedged of interest rate risk |
Hedges of foreign exchange risk |
Central treasury |
Normal purchase/sale exception |
Enrique, I plan to add a short list of other significant areas constituents asked be amended but the Board decided not to. I don't think it will take more than a few minutes to briefly summarize. |
"Market interest rate risk" has
been replaced with the concept of interest rate risk: From the risk free rate (US Treasury) plus "sector" risk To a benchmark interest rate - LIBOR swap rate or US Treasury rate |
More difficult to hedge credit risk since sector spread is part of credit risk |
Benchmark interest rate being hedged must
be: Specifically identified as part of designation Documented at inception of the relationship Ordinarily the same benchmark rate for similar hedges |
To qualify for the short cut method, the index on which the variable leg of the swap is based must MATCH the benchmark rate designated as the risk being hedged |
Use of a LIBOR based swap to hedge the change in fair value due to LIBOR changes of even highly rated (AAA) debt instruments is now permitted |
The change in the hedged item's fair value
attributable to changes in the benchmark interest rate: Must be based upon the contractual cash flows of the entire hedge item Excluding some of these cash flows (e.g., the portion of the interest coupon in excess of the benchmark interest rate) is not permitted No required discount rate given; therefore, an entity may use the benchmark interest rate or the hedged item's coupon rate (adjusted for changes to benchmark) as the discount rate. |
Entity is permitted to use: (1) a LIBOR based instrument to hedge the change in cash flows of a variable rate instrument that resets based on the US Treasury or (2) a Treasury based instrument to hedge the change in cash flows of a variable rate instrument that resets based on LIBOR |
The designated risk being hedged for a variable rate financial asset or liability (either existing or forecasted) can NOT be the benchmark interest rate if the cash flows of the hedged transaction are explicitly based on a different index (e.g., Prime). |
Instead, an entity may be able to designate the overall changes in cash flows as the hedged risk and not just interest rate risk |
Foreign-currency-denominated (FCD) asset or liability can be hedged in fair value or cash flow hedge |
Unrecognized FCD firm commitments also can be hedged in fair value or cash flow hedge |
Cash flow hedging of a recognized FCD asset or liability is permitted only when ALL the variability in the hedged item's functional currency equivalent cash flows is fixed |
Revisions permit hedge accounting where,
previously, only "natural hedging" was permitted Minimizes the spot/forward difference created by SFAS 133 while Retaining the concepts of marking-to-spot the asset or liability under SFAS 52 and marking-to-market the derivative under SFAS 133 |
Provisions for hedging AFS Securities remain substantially unchanged |
Hedging other recognized assets or
liabilities that give rise to FX transaction gains or losses Adjust the FCD asset or liability for interest changes in the foreign currency (presuming interest-rate risk is also hedged) Then mark-to-spot the adjusted FCD asset or liability |
Report the change in fair value of derivatives deemed effective (including the forward premium in OCI. |
Release to earnings amount equal to mark-to-spot adjustment of asset or liability. Release to earnings remaining amount (forward premium) as yield adjustment over time. |
Debt terms |
|
Hedge Objective |
|
Derivative |
|
Result |
|
Approach |
|
Hedging with intercompany derivative ALLEGEDLY simplified |
Intercompany foreign currency derivatives
would be permitted to be designated as cash flow hedges (in the
consolidated financial statements) of the following: Forecasted borrowings Purchases or sales Unrecognized firm commitments |
Only if those intercompany derivatives are offset by third party derivatives on a net bases |
"Net hedging" not extended to: Any other cash flow hedge or fair value hedges of foreign currency risk (e.g., fair value or cash flow hedges of recognized foreign currency denominated assets or net investment in foreign operations), or Hedges of any other risk such as interest rates |
Central treasury must act as a pass-through
entity: Must enter into third-party contracts to offset, on a net basis for each foreign currency The foreign exchange risk arising from multiple internal derivatives AND the derivative contract with the unrelated third party must general equal or closely approximating gains and losses when compared with the aggregate or net losses and gains generated by the intercompany derivative contracts |
Due to concerns regarding macro-hedging,
central treasury (or Issuing Affiliate): Must track exposures and document linkage of all derivatives Cannot alter or terminate third-party contracts unless Hedging Affiliate initiates action Must reassess compliance with all requirements if the internal derivative is modified or de-designated as a hedge |
Can only combine exposure from internal contracts that involve the same currency and mature within the same 31-day period |
Offsetting net third-party contract must: Offset the aggregate or net exposure to that currency Mature within the same 31-day period Be entered into within 3 business days after the designation of internal contracts as hedging instruments |
Normal purchase/sale exception expanded to
include: Contracts that permit net settlement (9a) Contracts that have a market mechanism to facilitate net settlement (9b) |
Entity must determine that it is probable at inception and throughout the term that the contract will not be settled net AND will result in physical settlement (intent based) |
Contracts that do not qualify for the
exception: Those requiring cash settlement or otherwise settling periodically (e.g., futures contracts) Those having a price based on an underlying not clearly and closely related to asset sold or purchased, such as:
An individual contract that
will settle net if it is part of a series of sequential contracts intended |
DIG Issue G3, "Discontinuation
of a Cash Flow Hedge": Gain or loss continues to be reported in OCI unless it is probable that the forecasted transaction will not occur by the originally specified time period or within an additional two month period Extenuating circumstances resulting in the continued reporting in OCI beyond that two-month period:
|
DIG Issue H2, "Requirements
That the Unit With the Exposure Must Be Party to the Hedge": For consolidated financial statements, either:
|
DIG Issue H5, "Hedging a
Firm Commitment or a Fixed-Price Agreement Denominated in a Foreign
Currency": Unrecognized foreign-currency-denominated firm commitment can be designated in either a fair value or a cash flow hedge Earlier position reaching the same conclusion for payments due under an AFS debt security (by analogizing to this issue), is explicitly permitted by SFAS 138 |
|
9/30/X1 | 12/31/X1 | 3/31/X1 | |
JCN shares (100,000 shares) JCN per share |
$1,050,000 $105 |
$940,000 $94 |
$900,000 $90 |
Put options (100,000 options) Put options each Intrinsic value Time Value |
$14,500 $1.45 $0 $1.45 |
$36,700 $3.67 $1.00 $2.67 |
$50,000 $5.00 $5.00 $0 |
Volatility Risk-free rate Dividend Yield |
20% 5% 0% |
20% 5% 0% |
$20% 5% 0% |
Definition, Scope and
Embedded Derivatives
FAS 133 introduces a broad
characteristics-based definition: Underlying and (1) Notional Amount or (2) Payment Provision Little or no initial investment Net settlement provisions |
Major change in existing practice |
Derivatives are carried on the balance sheet at FV with offset to the income statement unless restrictive hedge accounting criteria are met |
If hedge accounting criteria are met, accounting for the offset will be driven by the hedge accounting model used (cash flow, fair value or net investment in a foreign affiliate) |
Even with hedge accounting, ineffective portion affects earnings (increased P&L volatility) |
|
Forwards, futures, options and swaps will continue to be derivatives |
Other contracts may be derivatives subject to FAS 133 depending on the characteristics of the contract |
Provisions to look for in contracts: Terms indicating a notional amount/payment provision (minimum take provisions; liquidated damages clauses; etc.); "requirements-only" contracts do not contain a notional amount Terms indicating net settlement (see previous slide) |
The net settlement criterion is met if:
|
Warrants Critical criteria to be evaluated is net settlement Public co. warrants will typically be derivatives unless: Significant restrictions exist Volumes at which the warrants can be exercised result in public stock not being readily convertible to cash Private co. warrants may not be derivatives; depends on whether net settlement provisions are contained in the document or a market mechanism exists (look out for put options and special arrangements with investment bankers) |
Financial Guarantees Are the payment provisions based on losses associated with insurable events? Payments in response to changes in an underlying are most often derivatives, NOT financial guarantees
|
Guarantee and reimbursement (G&R)
agreements:
|
DIG Issue A2 "Existence of a Market Mechanism That Facilitates Net Settlement |
DIG Issue A3 "Impact of Market Liquidity on the Existence of a Market Mechanism" |
Agenda Item 10-2 "Derivative Treatment of Stock Purchase Warrant for Temporarily Restricted Stock |
Future Agenda Item. "Designation of a Stock Purchase Warrant as an All-In-One Cash Flow Hedge" |
Slide #11 G&R Agreement Illustration AND
Slide #10 Definition, Scope and Embedded Derivatives GO HERE
Embedded features meet the definition of a derivative |
Hybrid instrument (i.e., the overall instrument) is not measured at fair value with the effect in earnings |
Economic characteristics and risks of embedded derivative are not clearly and closely related to host contract |
Requires Detailed Understanding of Contract Provisions; Little Doubt that Some "Sleepers" Still Exist |
Value of Host Contract | Driven By | Underlying Index |
Debt instrument | ![]()
|
Interest rates Prepayment terms Inflation rates Creditworthiness |
Equity instrument | ![]() |
Equity of issuer |
Lease instrument | ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Inflation rates Interest rates Expected revenues |
Instruments which change one interest rate
to another (e.g., variable rate debt) are generally viewed as clearly and
closely related
BUT, if it is possible for the investor:
...Then not clearly and closely related |
Account for "host contract" under existing accounting principles; |
Account for the embedded derivative in accordance with this Statement - thus can be a hedging instrument |
Inability to separate embedded derivative from contract results in fair value treatment for the entire instrument and forfeiture of ability to qualify as a hedging instrument |
I/O strips
Even though we may not recover substantially all of our initial net investment under terms of contract, they may be excluded from the standard if:
Note that some I/O's:
|
Must first determine whether the
Beneficial Interest (BI) is in the form of debt or equity DIG did not provide guidance in this area Should consider EITF Issue 89-4, "Accounting for Purchased Investment in a Collateralized Mortgage Obligation or in a Mortgage-Backed IO Certificate" |
||
If BI is in the form of debt, there is an embedded derivative if it incorporates a return other than interest rates | ||
QSPE's Assets | BIs | Embedded? |
Example 1: SPE Holds a fixed-rate and an interest rate swap | BIs provide a guaranteed return of principal, a stated interest rate, and potential for an equity-based upside | No |
Example 2: SPE Holds a Treasury Bills and an equity-linked option | BIs provide a variable return based on LIBOR | Yes |
Example 3: SPE Holds a FC-denominated variable-rate bond and a FC interest rate swap | BIs provide a fixed interest-rate return denominate in the investors' functional currency | No |
Consider the following examples
(in all cases the BI is deemed to be debt)
|
Lease contract host
|
Insurance contract host
|
Special rules for variable annuities
|
Mandatorily deliverable debt indexed to
equity: Can require delivery of shares, net cash settlement, or provide for a settlement option Ultimate repayment of debt instrument is indexed to market price of the stock Can be structured in a variety of ways. For embedded derivative to qualify as a hedge it must be a:
|
Not Required to be Separated from Host
Contract
Required to be Separated from Host Contract
|
Hedging: Effectiveness &
Concept of Similar Items
Overview of Hedging
Management of Market-Related Risks |
Example risks:
|
Example hedging instruments:
|
Cash flow hedge accounting is used to hedge variability
in cash flows associated with:
|
Fair value hedge accounting is used to hedge
an entity's exposure to changes in fair value, attributable to a
particular risk, relating to:
|
Hedging of a net investment in a foreign operation continues to be allowed |
Formal documentation of the hedging relationship, its objectives and strategy, and its effectiveness |
The hedging relationship must be expected to be highly effective at inception and on an ongoing basis |
There are special rules for using written options and basis swaps as hedging instruments |
At inception, must document:
|
Additional documentation required for:
|
FAS 133 does not allow hedge accounting for
the following items:
|
|
Ongoing:
|
If an improved measurement method is
identified then:
|
If high effectiveness ceases:
|
Derivative | ![]() |
Principal & notional amounts | ![]() |
Hedged Item |
Derivative | ![]() |
Counterparty creditworthiness | ![]() |
Hedged Item |
Derivative | ![]() |
Term or maturity | ![]() |
Hedged Item |
Derivative | ![]() |
Fair value at inception and re-pricing dates |
![]() |
Hedged Item |
Derivative | ![]() |
Cash receipts or payment dates | ![]() |
Hedged Item |
Derivative | ![]() |
Underlying basis (e.g., LIBOR versus Prime) |
![]() |
Hedged Item |
Utilization of an IRS to synthetically alter fixed rate debt to a floating rate obligation |
Utilization of FX forwards/swaps on foreign currency denominated transactions (e.g., foreign denominated debt) |
Available when key terms of an interest rate swap and hedged items meets certain conditions |
Accounting model: Assume perfectly effective No requirement to reassess effectiveness |
Short-cut method may not be used for hedges of risks other than interest rate risk (e.g., foreign currency risk) |
All:
|
Cash Flow Hedges
|
Fair Value Hedges
|
Forward contract Spot price Interest (time value) Carrying costs |
Option Intrinsic value Time value
|
Market arbitrage effects |
Only specified components may be excluded: |
For option contracts Intrinsic value: Time value can be excluded Minimum value (intrinsic + discounting): Volatility value can be excluded |
For a Forward or Futures Contract Spot prices: Difference between spot and forward/futures price can be excluded |
Excluded Portion is Included in Earnings Based on Its Changes in Fair Value |
Equity securities hedging - options Typically use only intrinsic value to assess effectiveness; therefore, time value will be recognized in income each period |
Foreign currency denominated variable rate
debt hedged using short-term forwards Management may decide not to apply hedge accounting for these instruments given their short tenor |
FX hedging - swap/forward Management must determine whether to assess effectiveness based on spot or forward rate |
FX hedging - option DIG currently reviewing this issue; tentative indications appear to require the use of spot FX rate in determining the intrinsic value of an option |
Pools of items Loans with similar interest rates and maturities FX exposures |
Multiple hedging instruments (combination of options and swaps) |
Dynamic hedging Mortgage servicing rights Interest only strips and other prepayable financial instruments |
A hedge must be highly effective at inception and on an ongoing basis |
Effectiveness will be measured at the end of each quarter |
Evaluation of effectiveness must be consistent with the entity's risk management strategy |
Even though a hedge may be highly effective, the income statement may still contain hedge ineffectiveness |
Currently, there is no definitive method of evaluating hedge effectiveness |
Prospectively, mark-to-market derivative through earnings |
For cash flow accounting, amount in OCI is evaluated for removal based on the forecasted transaction (or future cash settlement) (i.e., if the forecasted transaction remains probable, the amount will remain in OCI until the transaction occurs) |
For fair value accounting, previous basis adjustments are accounted for based on the underlying item (i.e., if the hedged item was a loan, the adjusted basis (discount/premium) would be amortized to earnings consistent with current accounting for discounts/premiums on loans) |
Fair Value Hedging:
GE Examples
Fair Value Hedge
Definition |
Accounting Model Under SFAS 133 |
Firm Commitments |
Examples |
Short-Cut Method |
Fair value hedge provides protection against changes in value caused by fixed terms, rates, or prices | |
Example Exposures
|
|
Swap |
Debt |
Derivative recorded at fair value through earnings | ||
Hedged item's carrying amount adjusted for changes in fair value attributable to hedged risk for all the contractual cash of the entire hedged item. | ||
Movement in derivative and underlying may not be equal (difference = ineffectiveness) | ||
Hedge ineffectiveness recorded in current earnings | ||
Measurement of Derivative Change in Fair Value |
+ ![]() |
Earnings |
Measurement of Hedge Item Offsetting Gain or Loss Attributable to Risk Being Hedged for all Contractual Cash Flows |
- ![]() |
|
|
SWAP |
DEBT |
What Would You Designate as the Hedged Item? |
|
Pre-Amendment: The overall change in fair value of the hedged item for changes in "market interest rate risk". Post-Amendment: The change in fair value of the hedged item for changes in the LIBOR (benchmark) interest rate component of the hedged item. |
|
Post-Amendment Provisions Should Reduce Potential Volatility. | |
How Do You Calculate Ineffectiveness? |
|
Change in the FV of the
Derivative Less: Pre-Amendment: Changes in FV of the Hedged Item only for Changes in "Market Interest Rate Risk" |
|
Ineffectiveness will result from changes in the non-customer specific credit spread on the hedged item | |
Change in the FV of the Derivative Less: |
|
Ineffectiveness will result from differences between the credit spread in the hedged item and the derivative contract. |
Change in Interest Rates |
||||
Type of Instrument Interest Rate Swap Hedged Debt Obligation |
Change in |
Recorded |
Not |
|
Change in FV of hedged debt obligation
due to change in: |
Derivative | Underlying | ||
Measurement | MTM | MTM | ||
Recognition | I/S | I/S | ||
Change in Interest Rates |
||||
Type of Instrument Interest Rate Swap Hedged Debt Obligation |
Change in |
Recorded |
Not |
|
*Ineffectiveness of 2 **Impact due to change in customer credit risk |
Derivative | Underlying | |||
Measurement | ||||
Recognition | ||||
Change in Interest Rates |
||||
Type of Instrument Interest Rate Swap Hedged Debt Obligation |
Change in |
Recorded |
Not |
|
Change in FV of hedged debt obligation
due to change in: |
Derivative | Underlying | ||
Measurement | MTM | MTM | ||
Recognition | I/S | I/S | ||
Change in Interest Rates |
||||
Type of Instrument Interest Rate Swap Hedged Debt Obligation |
Change in |
Recorded |
Not |
|
*Ineffectiveness of (0.5) **Impact due to change in total credit risk |
Contract
|
||
"Firm Commitments" and "Forecasted Transactions" NOT Interchangeable & subject to different accounting model | ||
Significant Disincentive for
Non-Performance DIG Issue F-3 |
||
Legal jurisdiction that governs the agreement provides remedies for default equivalent to the damages suffered in the event of non performance |
= |
Significant Disincentive for Non-Performance |
For non financial asset/liability hedged risk
must be entire change in FV E.G. Chocolate bar - cocoa - butter - milk |
Cocoa Derivative can be used to hedge chocolate bar if highly effective |
For financial asset/liability
can hedge separate risk components of market price risk EURO Bond - default (credit) risk - interest rate risk - foreign exchange risk |
|
The following items are
prohibited
|
Available when key terms of an interest rate swap and hedged items meet certain conditions |
Accounting model: Assume perfectly effective No requirement to reassess effectiveness |
ALL: |
Notional amount matches principal |
FV of swap at inception is zero |
Net settlements computed in same way |
Hedged item is not prepayable |
Other terms are typical |
Expiration dates match |
No floor or ceiling |
Re-pricing intervals frequent |
Notional amount does not match |
FV of swap at inception is not zero |
Net settlements computed in different way |
Hedged item is prepayable |
Expiration dates do not match |
Floor or ceiling exists |
Re-pricing intervals infrequent |
Differing credit spread in swap and hedged item |
EXAMPLES
D. Brain and Company: Accounting for Interest Rate Swaps in a Horizontal Yield Curve Environment | |
Existing Financial Instrument
|
Risk Management Objective
|
Hedging Derivative Receive-fixed, pay-variable interest rate swap
|
Specific Risk Being Hedged
|
Method of Assessing Hedge Effectiveness
|
End of Year 1
|
W. Ielusic Cigar Company: Accounting for Options Hedging Equity Securities | |
Existing Financial Instrument
|
Risk Management Objective
|
Hedging Derivative
|
Specific Risk Being Hedged
|
|
FAIR VALUE HEDGE with PUT OPTIONS
Purchased
Options 22,200 G. on Hedging Ops 10,000 Gain on Options 12,200 (Split gain in effective, ineffective; not required for correct I/S impact) Loss on Securities
10,000 |
Purchased
Options
13,400 Loss on Options 26,600 G. on Hedging Ops 40,000 (Break gain into effective, ineffective; not required) Cash
950,000 |
Loss on Sale
(AFS)
50,000 Reclass. Adj. 50,000 (Since hedging started, 50,000 loss on unhedged portion of AOCI deferred in AOCI; now realized) |
Fair value hedge provides protection against changes in value caused by fixed terms, rates or prices |
SFAS 133 Accounting Model
|
Cash Flow Hedging:
Cash Flow Hedge
What Is A Cash Flow Hedge |
Accounting Model Under SFAS 133 |
Forecasted Transactions |
Case Study |
A cash flow hedge provides protection against exposure to fluctuations in the cash flows associated with a hedged item caused by variable rates, terms or prices. | ||
Sample Exposures
|
||
How a typical cash flow hedge works |
SWAP
|
DEBIT |
Derivative measured at fair and recognized as an asset/liability | ||
Hedged item's carrying amount remains unchanged | ||
Change in FV of derivative is compared to change in future cash flows (or PV of future cash flows) | ||
Difference may go either to OCI or current earnings | ||
Measurement of
Derivative
Change in Fair Value
|
Effective![]() Ineffective ![]() |
Recognition
OCI |
(1) |
||
Earnings |
Plan
|
"Firm Commitments" and "Forecasted Transactions" NOT interchangeable & subject to different accounting model |
Joe's Computer Company: Cash Flow Hedge Accounting for an Interest Rate Swap in a Horizontal Yield Curve Environment | |
Existing Financial Instrument
|
Risk Management Objective
|
Hedging Derivative
|
Specific Risk Being Hedged
|
Method of Assessing Hedge Effectiveness
|
Swap Pricing/Assumptions
|
|
|
|
|
A cash flow hedge provides protection against exposure to fluctuations in the cash flows associated with a hedged item caused by variable rates, terms or prices. |
SFAS 133 Accounting Model
|
F/X
Hedging Foreign Currency Exposure
Brief history concerning the FX section of SFAS 133 |
Review of FX provisions prior to amendment by SFAS 138 |
Overview of revised FX hedge accounting |
Fair value FX hedging |
Cash flow FX hedging |
Hedging net investments in foreign operations |
Basic idea was to avoid reinventing the
wheel: Preserve the basic elements of SFAS 52 Expand the "hedging provisions" of SFAS 52 to address forecasted transactions Ensure the fundamentals of the D&H document were followed |
These objectives led to certain frustrating "anomalies" |
Functional Currency: "An entity's functional currency is the currency of the primary economic environment in which the entity operates; normally, that is the currency of the environment in which an entity primarily generates and expends cash." |
Translation of foreign currency statements |
Foreign currency transactions:
|
All derivative instruments recognized and measured at fair value |
Recognized assets and liabilities giving rise to foreign currency transaction gains or losses under SFAS 52 could not be hedged. |
Nonderivative instruments giving rise to transaction gains or losses could be designated as hedging instruments (but only for hedges of FX firm commitments and net investments in foreign operations) |
Hedges for forecasted transactions were permitted |
SFAS 133 initially provided for some "subtle" yet significant changes to the accounting model for FX exposures |
A fair value hedge of a foreign-currency-denominated: (1) firm commitment (excludes intercompany) or (2) available-for-sale security (debt and certain equity securities) |
A cash flow hedge of a foreign-currency-denominated (1) forecasted transaction (including intercompany), (2) unrecognized firm commitment, or (3) AFS debt security |
A hedge of a net investment in a foreign operation (similar to existing approach under SFAS 52) |
"Natural hedging" was a significant part of SFAS 133 prior to the recent amendment |
Proposed amendment removes the preclusion
from hedging recognized assets or liabilities that give rise to foreign
currency transaction gains or losses Reduces (but will not always eliminate) P&L volatility Permits hedging with certain compound derivatives (e.g., one that alters both interest rate and currency characteristics) |
Issues remain regarding hedges of net investments of foreign operations. |
Hedged Item | Fair Value Hedge | Cash Flow Hedge |
Forecasted FX denominated (FXD) transactions | ![]() |
|
Forecasted intercompany transactions | ![]() |
|
Unrecognized FXD firm commitment | ![]() |
![]() |
Recognized fixed-rate FXD asset or liability | ![]() |
![]() |
Recognized AFS equity security | ![]() |
|
Recognized variable-rate FXD asset or liability | ![]() |
![]() |
|
Must meet general requirements for fair value or cash flow hedging |
Hedged transaction is denominated in a currency other than the hedging unit's functional currency |
Operating Unit that has the FX
exposure must either: - Be party to the hedging instrument - Benefit from a hedge designated by another member of the consolidated group that has the same functional currency as the operating unit |
If a unit other than the operating unit
designates the hedge: - The operating unit will not obtain hedge accounting in its stand-alone financial statements - There may be no intervening subsidiaries with a different functional currency from the operating unit |
|
Entire change in fair value (including changes from FX) of an FXD AFS debt security is generally included in OCI |
If the FXD AFS debt security is designated
as a hedged item in a fair value hedge: - Changes in fair value of the derivative included currently in earnings - Changes in fair value of the AFS debt security attributable to FX is also reported currently in earnings |
If the FXD AFS debt security is designated
as a hedged item in a cash flow hedge (Fixed rate FXD swapped to Fixed
rate functional currency denominated): - Changes in fair value of the derivative included in OCI - Changes in fair value of the AFS debt security attributable to FX remains reported currently in OCI - Changes in fair value of the derivative are removed from OCI into earnings as the interest income is recognized on the FXD AFS debt security |
To qualify for hedge accounting, the equity
security must expose the unit to FX risk: - Security is not traded in the investor's functional currency - Dividends (if any) on the security are all denominated in the same foreign currency expected to be realized upon sale |
If the FXD AFS debt security is designated
as a hedged item: - Changes in the fair value of the derivative included currently in earnings - Changes in fair value of the AFS equity security attributable to FX is also reported currently in earnings |
If the forecasted transaction is a group of individual forecasted FXD transactions, a forecasted inflow and a forecasted outflow of foreign currency cannot both be included in the same group |
If the hedged item is a recognized FXD asset or liability, ALL variability in the hedged item's functional-currency-equivalent cash flows must be eliminated (including variability other than FX exposures) |
Internal derivatives can be used in hedging certain cash flow exposures (details to be discussed later in the presentation) |
On July 1, 1999, GECC, (USD functional currency entity) issues a zero-coupon debt instrument with a notional amount of FC154,766.79 for FC96,098.00. The interest rate implicit in the debt is 10 percent. The debt will mature on June 30, 2004. GECC enters into a forward contract to buy FC154,766.79 in 5 years at the forward rate of 1.090148194 (USD cost $168,718.74) and designates the forward contract as a hedge of the variability of the USD functional currency equivalent cash flows on the debt. Because the currency, notional amount, and maturity of the debt and the forward contract match, GECC concludes that no ineffectiveness will result. The USD interest rate implicit in the forward contract is 11.028 percent. |
What once seemed to be the more friendly part of SFAS 133 has become a frustration |
On the surface: - Changes in fair value of the hedging derivative or non-derivative are included in CTA - Ineffectiveness recognized currently in earnings |
Ineffectiveness is caused by the following
(DIG Issue H8): - The notional amount of the hedging instrument being different from the hedged net investment - The hedging instrument is denominated in a different currency from the hedged net investment - Use of multiple underlyings: certain derivatives with multiple underlyings can be used for hedged accounting:
|
Ineffectiveness in a net investment hedge is
measured: - By comparing the changes in fair value of the hedging instrument with
- If the net of tax approach is used,
the "hypothetical" hedging instruments are adjusted for |
Assuming the beginning balance (or specified
portion thereof) of the net investment is documented as the basis for
assessing hedge effectiveness: - Effectiveness is assessed each time financial statements or earnings are reported and, at least, every three months - An entity is not required to redesignate hedging relationships more frequently that that, even when a significant transaction occurs (e.g., a dividend) in the interim period |
Problem 1 for GECC: - DIG determined (DIG Issue H8) that the "perfect" net investment hedge is an appropriate FXD forward - GECC cannot choose to designate only the intrinsic value changes in the forward contract for assessing effectiveness - Therefore, the entire "effective" change in the fair value of the forward is included in CTA, resulting in:
|
Problem 2 for GECC: - DIG determined (DIG Issue H10) that the combination of FXD debt and a derivative cannot, in tandem, be used to hedge a net investment - Consider the following example:
- Could move the Euro borrowing and related FX swap to a JPY functional currency entity |
SFAS 138 introduces the concepts of: - A Hedging Affiliate: Party in a consolidated group that has a FX exposure that is being hedged. In the GECC environment it might be an operating entity that has originated or acquired an asset denominated in a foreign currency - Issuing Affiliate: Party in a consolidated group that has issued an intercompany derivative to the Hedging Affiliate. In the GECC environment this would most likely be GECC treasury |
Hedges using internal derivatives survive in
consolidation only: - For specified FX cash flow exposures - If, from the perspective of the Hedging Affiliate, the relevant conditions (paragraph 40) for foreign currency cash flow hedge accounting is satisfied - If the Issuing affiliate, either:
|
Permitted to hedge fair value of foreign-currency denominated firm commitments | } 1 |
Permitted to hedge net investment in foreign operation | |
Cannot be used to hedge recognized assets or liabilities or forecasted transactions (Reversal of EITF Issues 96-15 & 97-7) | |
1 These continue to be the only two circumstances under SFAS 133 in which nonderivative instruments qualify for hedge accounting (nonderivative instrument used is marked to spot rates, not market value) |
Consider the following facts - GECC has a foreign operation with yen functional currency - GECC Treasury decides to "hedge" that net investment by funding it operations in Japanese Yen (JPY) |
Hedging with a non derivative vs. using a derivative (assume no ineffectiveness) |
FCD CASH INSTRUMENTS MAY PROVIDE HEDGING SOLUTIONS BUT AT AN ADDED COST |
Provisions of SFAS 52 still applicable |
Hedge accounting limited expanded by SFAS 138 to include recognized assets or liabilities that give rise to FX transaction gains and losses |
Approaches to cash flow and fair value hedges generally apply; however, there are a number of special rules that apply only to FX |